IGMT 014: Pumpkin Milkshakes in March


Hey Reader!

I was in the drive-thru at Sheetz the other day, craving an MTO turkey sub and trying to sneak in a win before another long night of practices. I pull up to the speaker, and the guy says, “Welcome to Sheetz, would you like to try our fall pumpkin milkshake today?” I pause. It’s March. I don’t even like pumpkin anything, but now I’m confused. Did I miss a whole season? Am I that tired? Did we fast-forward through summer and volleyball camp?

I ask him, “Wait... pumpkin?”
He chuckles and says, “Oh crap, wrong button. That’s from last October.”

And just like that, my brain, already running on caffeine and chaos, was off and spiraling. Because that’s exactly what I see happening all around me right now.

It’s still the regular season for a lot of our athletes. They’re smack in the middle of games, practices, tournaments, homework, and trying to stay sane. Yet here come the whispers and emails and Instagram posts. “Tryouts for next season start in four weeks.” “Are you returning next year?” “We’re forming our team now, spots are limited.” The athletes haven’t even taken off this season’s jersey, and already someone is handing them a new one to try on.

...and that got me thinking.

When did we start playing for the next team before we’re done playing for the one we’re on? Seriously. We’ve built this anxiety machine where kids are being asked to look ahead before they’re even finished with what’s right in front of them. It’s like telling someone to start thinking about Thanksgiving while they’re still chewing on their Easter candy. Chill. Let the chocolate bunny melt before we start talking turkey.

I get it. Coaches want to plan ahead. Clubs need to lock things in early. Parents want to make sure their kid has a spot. But the cost of that urgency is often overlooked. Instead of helping athletes stay focused and present, we’re pushing them into a state of doubt. If they’re not sure they’re wanted next season, how are they supposed to give everything to the rest of this one? If their brain is already juggling tryout drills, new coaches, and pressure from teammates or parents, what happens to their performance this weekend?

We can do better.

And that starts by slowing down and realizing what we’re doing. Coaches: don’t let tryout season steal your athlete’s joy in the current season. Reinforce that you see them now. You’re coaching the player they are today, not the player you might keep next year. Give feedback that helps them grow now, not just impress later.

Parents: resist the urge to whisper about next year in the car ride home. If your athlete brings it up, be there. Listen. But if they don’t, let them be in the moment. Let them play without the shadow of next season following them around like a clipboard with bad handwriting.

And athletes: I know it’s hard not to peek around the corner. You’re hearing chatter about tryouts and new teams and who’s going where. That’s normal. But don’t let it hijack what you’ve worked for all season. Trust that the best way to get to the next level is to crush the one you’re on right now. Show up. Be great today. The rest will sort itself out.

It’s easy to get caught up in the future, especially in a sports culture that never stops moving. But let’s be real, most of us barely know what we’re having for dinner tonight, let alone who’s playing libero next September. Be where your feet are. Teach your athletes to do the same.

Now if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to go back and double-check that the Sheetz guy isn’t stuck in a time loop. Or maybe I’ll just lean into it and ask when the Thanksgiving hoagie is back. Either way, let’s keep our eyes on the game in front of us.

A few nights ago, I walked into the gym to watch a match and saw a kid on the bench scrolling through his phone. I’m thinking, “Maybe he’s checking the score of another game, or reviewing game film?” Nope. He was looking at a social post from a different club announcing their tryouts. During his own game.

Look, I’m not judging the kid. I’m not even surprised anymore. But that’s the problem, right? We’ve normalized this race to what’s next so much that we don’t even flinch when a player checks out of their current team’s match to check in on what’s next. Wild.

So here’s my challenge to everyone this week: check in. Coaches, check in with your players. Parents, check in with your kids. Athletes, check in with yourselves. Not about next season or the team after this one. Ask how they’re feeling right now. What are they proud of from this season? What’s been hard? What still matters before it’s all over?

And then...this part’s important...actually listen.

Because this season? It still counts.

Until next time...

#DontSuck and remember—play today like it’s not already tomorrow.

For more resources such as blogs, vlogs, and upcoming webinars, visit DanMickle.com.

Also, visit MentalCast.com for the latest episode of The MentalCast podcast.

Upcoming Webinars
The Parent's Playbook: Supporting Your Athlete’s Mental Game (June 8, 2025) [More Info]
The Coach's Playbook: Supporting Your Athlete’s Mental Game (June 8, 2025) [More Info]

Here is the fine print..

Holy cow, you are actually reading the fine print on this email. You must be very meticulous, or you want me to stop sending you things. I really hope it is not the latter, but if it is, I will respect that. I will cry—a lot. But I will respect that. The links you are looking for are below (and not in white font).

This email was sent to: Reader

If you were forwarded this email and like me, you can subscribe here.

If you want to dance and have a song stuck in your head all day, click here.

Unsubscribe · Preferences · Privacy

IGMT by Dan Mickle and 717 Soul, LLC | 185 Newberry Commons #298, Etters PA 17070 USA

It Got Me Thinking...

It Got Me Thinking is a must-read newsletter that explores the mental side of performance, offering insights and strategies to strengthen mindset, build resilience, and unlock potential in sports, competition, and everyday life.

Read more from It Got Me Thinking...

Lets talk tryouts, Reader. I was at the park the other day, watching a group of kids try to conquer the jungle gym. One kid, who must have been around seven or eight, approached the highest bar with a determined look. But as he reached up, his hand hesitated just before grabbing it. You could see his mind racing: “What if I fall?” “What if I can’t do it?” After a few moments, he backed away, choosing a lower rung instead. His friend, who had seen him hesitate, walked over and said, "You’ll...

OK Reader, it is time to talk about loyalty. Imagine you’re at a local sports game, yours, a friend’s, or maybe your child’s. You’re sitting in the stands, enjoying the action, when, out of the corner of your eye, you spot a player on the field who seems out of place. They're wearing a new jersey, and they’re playing a position that’s usually filled by someone else. The more you think about it, the more you realize that the roster’s shifted again. The coach seems to have brought in some fresh...

Hey Hey Reader! It is that time of week! The other day, I was in a familiar situation: feeling overwhelmed, juggling multiple tasks, and trying to stay on top of everything. I was preparing for an important practice, ensuring the drills were set, mentally going over what needed to be done, and planning feedback to give the players. Suddenly, it hit me. My brain was buzzing with information, ideas, and plans. I felt like I was spinning in circles, unsure of where to focus first. It was like I...