The Version We Remember


The Version We Remember

Hi Reader.

There is something fascinating about listening to family members tell stories about things that happened years ago. You can have five people sitting around a table, all of whom were present for the same event, and somehow end up with six different versions of what happened. I say six because there is usually one person who changes their story halfway through the conversation once they realize the original version is not getting the reaction they wanted.

I have always enjoyed those conversations. Someone starts telling a story about a family vacation, a holiday gathering, or something ridiculous that happened when everyone was younger. The details get better with every retelling. The weather was worse, the drive was longer, someone was considerably angrier, and whatever went wrong was apparently a much bigger disaster than anyone realized at the time.

Eventually, someone interrupts with those four magical words: "That's not what happened!"

And now we have a problem. Because the person telling the story is absolutely convinced they are right, and the person correcting them is equally convinced that they are the only one at the table who remembers anything accurately. Before long, everyone is contributing evidence, questioning timelines, and occasionally calling upon someone who wasn't even there to settle the argument.

The best part is that nobody really cares about the original event anymore. The disagreement has become the entertainment. And if you bring up the same story next Thanksgiving, I can almost guarantee that everyone will tell it exactly the same way they did this year, corrections and all.

...and it got me thinking.

I wonder how much of our lives we evaluate through stories that might not be entirely accurate.

We tend to think of memory as a recording of what happened. Something occurs, our brain stores it, and later we pull it back out when we want to remember. Unfortunately, that is not quite how memory works. Our memories are reconstructed rather than simply replayed. We remember pieces of an experience, often the parts that carried the most emotional weight, and our minds work to make sense of everything around them.

That does not mean we are intentionally changing the facts or lying to ourselves. It means the version we remember may be influenced by how we felt, what we noticed, what happened afterward, and even how many times we have told the story.

I see this play out in sports all the time.

An athlete finishes a match and tells me they played terribly. When I ask what happened, they immediately describe a mistake they made at a critical moment. Maybe they missed a serve late in the set, made a poor decision, or failed to execute something they had practiced hundreds of times. They can describe that moment in remarkable detail. They remember the score, the reaction from the bench, and sometimes even the expression on their coach's face.

What they struggle to remember is everything else.

They forget the excellent plays they made earlier in the match. They overlook the difficult situations they handled well. They rarely mention the decisions that helped their team stay competitive or the improvements they demonstrated compared to previous performances. An entire afternoon of competing has somehow been reduced to a few seconds that did not go the way they wanted.

And because those seconds carried so much emotion, they begin to feel like an accurate representation of the entire experience.

I think coaches can be just as guilty of this. We finish a season and start evaluating what happened, but our memories often gravitate toward the moments that frustrated us the most. We remember the match we should have won, the practice that went poorly, or the conversation that did not produce the outcome we hoped for. Those moments become central to the story we tell ourselves about the season.

Meanwhile, there may have been dozens of quieter moments that deserve just as much attention. An athlete who struggled with confidence finally started trusting their decisions. A team that could barely communicate in August learned how to work through difficult situations together. Someone who was afraid to make mistakes became willing to take chances.

Those moments might not have produced a championship or even changed the final record, but they happened. They were part of the experience, too.

I have been thinking about this quite a bit as I reflect on my own coaching experiences. It is surprisingly easy to look backward and allow a handful of difficult moments to influence how I remember months or even years of work. There are decisions I would change, conversations I wish I had handled differently, and outcomes I certainly would have preferred to avoid. I can recall some of those moments with uncomfortable clarity.

But I also know there were good days. There were athletes who grew, relationships that mattered, practices that were genuinely fun, and moments that reminded me why I enjoyed coaching in the first place. Those memories deserve a place in the story, even if they are not always the first ones that come to mind.

The interesting part is that selective memory works in both directions. Sometimes we remember an experience as far better than it actually was. We romanticize the past, overlook the difficult parts, and convince ourselves that things used to be simpler or more enjoyable. I hear this frequently in conversations about youth sports. People talk about how much better things were when they played, often forgetting that their own coaches, parents, and teammates probably had plenty of complaints about the system back then, too.

Neither version necessarily gives us the complete picture.

This is where I think reflection becomes especially important. Not the kind where we sit around replaying everything that went wrong, but the kind where we become curious about the story we are telling ourselves. When an athlete says they played terribly, I am interested in understanding what that means. Was the entire performance poor, or did a few moments leave a particularly strong impression? When a coach describes a season as a failure, I wonder what they are using to make that determination.

There is a difference between remembering something accurately enough to learn from it and allowing one memory to define everything around it.

I also wonder how often the stories we tell about other people become just as selective. An athlete makes a mistake in an important moment, and suddenly they are someone who cannot handle pressure. A coach makes a questionable decision, and that becomes evidence that they do not understand their players. A child has one emotional reaction, and we begin describing them as someone who always struggles with frustration.

Those descriptions can become difficult to escape, especially when we repeat them enough that they start sounding like established facts.

Maybe that is the part that concerns me most. Our memories do not just influence how we understand the past. They can shape what we expect from ourselves and others in the future.

An athlete who remembers themselves as someone who always fails under pressure may carry that story into the next important moment. A coach who remembers a player primarily through their mistakes may begin looking for confirmation that the player has not changed. Eventually, the story becomes so familiar that we stop questioning whether it is still accurate.

I am not suggesting we ignore difficult experiences or pretend everything was wonderful. Mistakes matter. Disappointments matter. Sometimes a season really was difficult, and sometimes our decisions genuinely deserve criticism. But I think there is value in recognizing that the strongest memory is not necessarily the most representative one.

Perhaps a more complete understanding of an experience requires us to make room for things we did not immediately notice, or things we have gradually forgotten.

Which brings me back to those family stories.

I can almost picture the next holiday gathering, with someone bringing up an event from twenty years ago and another person immediately challenging the details. There will probably be some exaggerated gestures, a few accusations of selective memory, and at least one person insisting they have photographic evidence somewhere on an old phone or computer.

Eventually, everyone will laugh, the conversation will move on, and nobody will have officially admitted they were wrong.

I suspect that is how it should end. Not because the truth does not matter, but because sometimes the most interesting part of a shared experience is discovering that the people who lived through it alongside us remember something entirely different.

And maybe, somewhere between their version and ours, there is a little more of the story worth remembering.

Until next time, thanks for riding along!

Dan

P.S. If this brought a particular family story to mind, I would love to hear it. Especially if you are still convinced everyone else remembers it wrong.

If this issue got you thinking, share it on Facebook and drag a few friends into the conversation.

​[Share on Facebook]​

For more resources such as blogs, vlogs, and upcoming webinars, visit DanMickle.com.

Also, visit MentalCast.com for the latest episode of The MentalCast podcast.

Here is the fine print..

Holy cow, you are actually reading the fine print on this email. You must be very meticulous, or you want me to stop sending you things. I really hope it is not the latter, but if it is, I will respect that. I will cry—a lot. But I will respect that. The links you are looking for are below (and not in white font).
​
This email was sent to: Reader

If you were forwarded this email and like me, you can subscribe here.

If you want to dance and have a song stuck in your head all day, click here.
​
​
Unsubscribe · Preferences · Privacy

IGMT by Dan Mickle and 717 Soul, LLC | 185 Newberry Commons #298, Etters PA 17070 USA

It Got Me Thinking...

It Got Me Thinking is a must-read newsletter that explores the mental side of performance, offering insights and strategies to strengthen mindset, build resilience, and unlock potential in sports, competition, and everyday life.

Read more from It Got Me Thinking...
hot pizza

Pass a napkin please, Reader. There is something fascinating about the last slice of pizza. Picture the scene. A group of people has finished eating, the conversation is still going, and there is one lonely slice sitting in the box. Everyone knows it is there. Everyone has seen it. And I would be willing to bet that at least two people at the table still want it. Yet nobody takes it. Instead, we begin this strange little social dance where someone offers it to everyone else, everyone politely...

Get your coupons ready Reader. I have a theory that choosing the correct checkout line at the grocery store is one of life's great unsolved mysteries. I don't care how much experience you have or how carefully you study the situation. The moment you commit to a line, something will happen to make you question every decision you've ever made. You know the situation. You survey the registers, count the people, inspect the carts, and make what you believe is an educated decision. You get behind...

Spooky Logo

Boo! Did I scare you, Reader? Halloween is just a few days away, which means we are entering that wonderful time of year when people willingly spend money to dress up as something they are not. Some people spend months planning elaborate costumes, complete with makeup, accessories, and enough detail to make a Hollywood production jealous. Others grab a pair of sunglasses, throw on a hat, and announce that they are a character from a movie nobody remembers. I tend to appreciate the second...