IGMT 048: When the Moment Gets Loud


Pay attention Reader!

I was sitting at a stoplight the other day, radio on low, nothing urgent happening. Then the light turned green and the car behind me immediately laid on the horn. Not a tap. A full commitment. My body reacted before my brain did. Heart rate jumped. Hands tightened. I rushed my foot to the gas and pulled through the intersection faster than I needed to.

Nothing bad happened, but it struck me how quickly everything changed. Same car. Same road. Same skill set. One small moment of pressure and my timing, awareness, and decision making all shifted.

And it got me thinking...

We talk about pressure in sports almost exclusively through the lens of confidence. We assume pressure shows up because someone does not believe enough, is not mentally tough enough, or cannot handle the moment. But pressure rarely attacks confidence first. It attacks the system underneath performance.

Pressure changes how we perform because it changes how we process information.

The first thing pressure hits is attention. Under pressure, awareness narrows. Athletes stop seeing the full picture and lock onto one thing. One defender. One official. One mistake. One expectation. This is why players miss open teammates they normally see with ease. It is why hitters chase pitches they lay off every other day of the week. The brain is not panicking, it is filtering. It is choosing speed over breadth.

Timing is next. Pressure speeds things up. Pauses disappear. Rhythm breaks. Athletes rush plays that usually unfold naturally. Movements happen earlier than they should. Decisions get made before enough information is available. This is not about effort or carelessness. It is the body responding to urgency created by perceived stakes.

Then decision making takes the hit. Under pressure, the brain leans toward familiar and automatic responses. It defaults to habits rather than reading what is actually happening in front of you. Sometimes those habits work. Sometimes they do not. Either way, the choice is being made faster and with less context.

Here is the important part. None of this requires low confidence.

Many athletes experiencing pressure still believe they belong. They still care deeply. In fact, caring is often the doorway to pressure. The more meaningful the moment, the more the brain tries to protect against mistakes by tightening control. Ironically, that tightening often creates the very errors athletes fear.

This is where we get pressure wrong.

We tell athletes to calm down. Be confident. Relax. Trust yourself. Those messages are not wrong, but they are incomplete. Confidence does not automatically widen attention. Belief alone does not restore timing. Motivation does not slow decisions back to functional speed.

Pressure management is not about eliminating pressure or pumping confidence. It is about learning how to operate when the system tightens.

That is a skills conversation.

It is learning how to widen attention when it narrows. How to create space when urgency shows up. How to insert a pause, even a tiny one, before acting. How to notice when you are defaulting to habit instead of reading the moment.

The environment matters too. Sideline urgency, constant instruction, visible frustration, and outcome focused language all amplify attentional narrowing. So do the quiet stories athletes carry about roles, expectations, and what this moment is supposed to mean. Pressure does not always come from one loud source. Sometimes it builds silently.

The goal is not to perform without pressure. That is unrealistic. Pressure is a signal that the moment matters. The work is learning how to function when it shows up, before performance slips, before frustration takes over, before confidence gets blamed for something it did not cause.

That stoplight did not change my ability to drive. It changed how my brain processed the moment.

Pressure works the same way.

And noticing that might be the most important skill we can teach.

Until next time, remember, it is either one day or day one. The choice is yours.

For more resources such as blogs, vlogs, and upcoming webinars, visit DanMickle.com.

Also, visit MentalCast.com for the latest episode of The MentalCast podcast.

Athlete:365 Book is Now Available!

Every athlete wants to perform their best, but most forget that real growth starts in the mind. Athlete:365 is your daily mental performance guide designed to help you build focus, confidence, and resilience all year long.

Each month explores a new theme, from setting goals and creating routines to managing emotions, leading with purpose, and performing under pressure. Every daily entry gives you a short, actionable mindset lesson, a powerful quote, and a reflective journal prompt to help you build stronger habits one day at a time.

Here is the fine print..

Holy cow, you are actually reading the fine print on this email. You must be very meticulous, or you want me to stop sending you things. I really hope it is not the latter, but if it is, I will respect that. I will cry—a lot. But I will respect that. The links you are looking for are below (and not in white font).

This email was sent to: Reader

If you were forwarded this email and like me, you can subscribe here.

If you want to dance and have a song stuck in your head all day, click here.

Unsubscribe · Preferences · Privacy

IGMT by Dan Mickle and 717 Soul, LLC | 185 Newberry Commons #298, Etters PA 17070 USA

It Got Me Thinking...

It Got Me Thinking is a must-read newsletter that explores the mental side of performance, offering insights and strategies to strengthen mindset, build resilience, and unlock potential in sports, competition, and everyday life.

Read more from It Got Me Thinking...
Volleyball

IGMT #057 | Sometimes the next decision can wait. Reflection deserves its turn first. Hi Reader! The alarm was set for 5:00 a.m., but I was awake long before it went off. The room was quiet. Most of our bags were already packed, except for the usual collection of chargers, hoodies, and the things that somehow never seem to make it back into the suitcase until the last minute. I slid open the balcony door and stepped outside. The sun hadn't made its appearance yet, but the sky was beginning to...

Open Tabs

IGMT #056 | What if attention isn't the problem? What if it's volume? What a great day, Reader! I was working on some doctoral research the other day when I noticed my browser was slowing down. Nothing dramatic, just enough that I became aware of it. Since my first instinct is always to blame technology before myself, I started looking around to see what was going on. That's when I noticed the top of my screen. Thirty-seven tabs. Research articles. Volleyball websites. Amazon pages. ADHD...

Cluttered desktop

IGMT #055 | Somewhere between too many ideas and not enough finished ones. Hello again, Reader. I opened my laptop three different times this week to work on this newsletter. The first time, I ended up reorganizing folders instead. The second time, I somehow convinced myself that I needed to clean up old podcast outlines before I could possibly write something new. Which naturally led me into rereading unfinished blog drafts, half-built course ideas, random voice notes, and at least seven...